article-img

Editor’s Take: ‘Robbery’ Persists As Long As Current Scoring System Stays

1 years ago By Jhon Woug

The artful and tough sport of boxing is often met with endless controversy, particularly when it comes to determining scores. Boxing News’ recent edition highlights the divergent views surrounding fight scoring, emphasising how the ongoing debate challenges the pursuit of an undisputed answer in a contentious decision-making arena.

Mikaela Mayer feels a sense of injustice, while Natasha Jonas experiences relief, and Maxi Hughes believes he was cheated. These conflicting sentiments arise in the aftermath of George Kambosos’ contested win over Hughes, which has granted him an opportunity to fight Vasyl Lomachenko. This amplifies the difficulty for boxing in navigating through controversial situations.

Prominent bantamweight Jason Moloney joins the many expressing concern over boxing’s 10-point-must system. He believes that its intricate nature repels new fans by making it difficult for the general public to understand how fights are scored and ultimately hinders growth within the sport’s audience.

October’s match between Tyson Fury and Francis Ngannou had a significant impact. Despite the belief that Ngannou delivered stronger hits, he only managed to knock down his opponent once, leaving many viewers puzzled. The discussion surrounding the judges’ scores sparked concerns of manipulation, which took away from recognising an impressive performance by an underdog player.

Re-evaluating the match without the element of surprise, it becomes evident on the judges’ scorecards that Fury emerged victorious. Nonetheless, in an era where immediate satisfaction is preferred, anticipating fans to watch a fight again for better comprehension of scoring seems impractical, particularly for those who are new to boxing.

The essential issue at hand is the requirement for a complete restructuring of the existing system. If there isn’t significant change, uncertainty and feelings of unjust gains will remain prevalent. In this modern age requiring quick results, transparency in delivering fairness must be prioritised to facilitate advancement within the sports domain. The fundamental rules governing triumph or loss should be straightforward enough for audiences from various backgrounds to comprehend, matching comparable clarity observed across other sports industries’ policies towards visibility in their processes and operations.

At the dawn of boxing, simplicity was crucial. The ultimate winner emerged as the sole survivor, relying solely on endurance. However, with changing societal standards came an increased demand for a more complex methodology. Today’s approach consists of predetermined rounds that are assessed separately by three judges with different perspectives, potentially resulting in discrepancies from those observing from afar.

In contrast to many other sports, boxing is particularly susceptible to the consequences of scoring inconsistencies. A debatable outcome can significantly impede or even ruin an athlete’s career, as evidenced by Jack Catterall’s path after his defeat on points against Josh Taylor in 2019. In boxing, victory and defeat carry a heightened significance that amplifies the influence of flawed assessments.

According to Carl Fail, a super-welterweight boxer, diversity in opinions is an essential aspect of the charm that boxing offers. The subjective nature of this sport adds to its entertainment value since individuals form their own distinct viewpoints. Although it has value for the sport as a whole, there are still calls for change from some quarters.

Open scoring, a suggested adjustment in judging criteria for combat sports competitions, involves the disclosure of judges’ scores after each round or series. Advocates contend that this transparency would provide fighters and audiences with immediate comprehension of the scorecard. Nevertheless, critics are wary that it may influence judges according to audience responses as opposed to objective assessment, which could result in inaccuracies and confusion. Additionally, opponents fear open scoring allows boxers who have thought they have secured victory early on to utilise defensive manoeuvres rather than high-energy offensive battle tactics, thereby diminishing competition suspense until final decision announcement time.

Boxing faces the daunting task of preserving both drama and impartiality, thus striking an equilibrium. The lingering inquiry is how the sport can progress to incorporate transparency while still retaining its distinct suspense before the judges’ verdict.

The age-old question of how to score boxing matches fairly, transparently, and in a way that’s understandable both for hardcore fans and newcomers still plagues the sport. However, there may be hope by implementing open scoring reforms while managing to balance tradition with modern demand from diverse audiences. Nevertheless, until then, accusations of ‘robbery’ will continue to haunt this noble art.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest


0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
More Recommendations
Unlock a World of Endless Discoveries: Your Personalized Recommendation Engine
article-image

The biggest event on the WWE calendar, Survivor Series, is coming up this Saturday live from the TD Garden in… Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
article-image

Even before the biggest superstar in sports entertainment has stepped foot in the ring, a list of superstars and celebrities… Read More

1 years ago Jhon Woug
article-image

The world of professional wrestling is a stage of fierce competition and high-flying action, where wrestlers often push their bodies… Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
article-image

In the high-stakes world of professional mixed martial arts, where fighters are celebrated for their resilience and determination. UFC flyweight… Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
article-image

As one of the most exciting shifts in the WWE women’s division over the years, Nia Jax has returned to… Read More

9 months ago Jhon Woug
article-image

For nearly three decades, Michael Cole has been a constant presence in WWE’s broadcast booth, evolving from a straight-laced play-by-play… Read More

4 months ago Jhon Woug
Stories Going Viral
Unleashing the Power of Stories
article-image

The Women’s Revolution in WWE has been one characterized by growth, breaking through barriers, and changing the role of the… Read More

11 months ago Jhon Woug
article-image

The earth just split in two with this major announcement that next month John Cena will make his return to… Read More

1 years ago Jhon Woug
article-image

In the world of professional wrestling, there are very few athletes that are as highly regarded and respected as Randy… Read More

9 months ago Jhon Woug
article-image

World Wrestling Entertainment’s NXT brand is set to deliver another exhilarating episode tonight, November 7, 2023, from the Capital Wrestling… Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
article-image

In the latest WWE SmackDown episode, wrestling star Edge had what might be the final match of his current contract…. Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
article-image

Kevin Holland came up short in his UFC Night bout with Jack Della Maddalena. However, he wasted no time in… Read More

1 years ago Sports Desk
Join Our Exclusive Newsletter and Stay in the Loop!
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x